Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

World

UN court says it can rule in Bolivia vs Chile row

-

The UN's highest court Thursday agreed to take up a century-old dispute between Chile and Bolivia, saying it could rule in the case as La Paz seeks to regain access to the Pacific.

The Hague-based International Court of Justice (ICJ), which oversees disputes between countries, said it "has jurisdiction... to entertain the application filed by Bolivia."

A hearing dealing with the substance of the case however is not expected to open for several months.

Bolivia -- South America's poorest country -- became landlocked after losing a four-year war against Chile at the end of the 19th century, forfeiting territory and its access to the sea.

The two countries have had only limited diplomatic relations since 1978.

After a number of fruitless negotiations with Santiago over the issue, La Paz lodged a complaint to the ICJ in April 2013.

Bolivia wants the ICJ to order Santiago to negotiate "in good faith" to restore its access to the Pacific via the Atacama -- the world's driest non-polar desert.

Judges sit at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in the Hague on September 24  2015  to delive...
Judges sit at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in the Hague on September 24, 2015, to deliver the court's judgment
Jerry Lampen, ANP/AFP

But La Paz has not specifically asked the court to rule directly on whether it has a right to access.

Santiago dismissed the case, saying the ICJ, set up in 1946 did not have jurisdiction to rule in the matter.

Chilean President Michelle Bachelet said Bolivia "had not won anything" with Thursday's ruling.

The decision "does not affect our territorial integrity," she said, adding the "only thing the court has so far decided is that is the apt tribunal to hear Bolivia's request, without yet making any determination about the case."

Chile says its territorial sovereignty was defined by treaties signed in 1904 and 1948 which prevent an international court from interfering in the matter and that today it was still governed by these treaties.

However, the treaties do not mention "Chile's alleged obligation to negotiate Bolivia's access" to the sea and therefore "Chile's objection to jurisdiction... must accordingly be dismissed," ICJ judge Ronny Abraham said.

Chilean president Michelle Bachelet speaks during a press conference at La Moneda Presidential Palac...
Chilean president Michelle Bachelet speaks during a press conference at La Moneda Presidential Palace in Santiago, on September 24, 2015
Ximena Navarro, Presidencia/AFP

Bolivia will also be encouraged by a judgement by the ICJ in January 2014 which gave Peru some of the maritime territory that had been under Chile's control since the 19th century war.

Bolivian President Evo Morales on Thursday urged Santiago to open negotiations on the issue on learning of the court's decision.

"We are a peaceful country, and I would like to ...call on the government of Chile to accompany this process through dialogue," Morales said from his official residence in La Paz.

But Bachelet shot back that Bolivia's case "has no basis as it is confusing the law with aspirations and completely distorting the history between Chile and Bolivia."

The UN’s highest court Thursday agreed to take up a century-old dispute between Chile and Bolivia, saying it could rule in the case as La Paz seeks to regain access to the Pacific.

The Hague-based International Court of Justice (ICJ), which oversees disputes between countries, said it “has jurisdiction… to entertain the application filed by Bolivia.”

A hearing dealing with the substance of the case however is not expected to open for several months.

Bolivia — South America’s poorest country — became landlocked after losing a four-year war against Chile at the end of the 19th century, forfeiting territory and its access to the sea.

The two countries have had only limited diplomatic relations since 1978.

After a number of fruitless negotiations with Santiago over the issue, La Paz lodged a complaint to the ICJ in April 2013.

Bolivia wants the ICJ to order Santiago to negotiate “in good faith” to restore its access to the Pacific via the Atacama — the world’s driest non-polar desert.

Judges sit at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in the Hague on September 24  2015  to delive...

Judges sit at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in the Hague on September 24, 2015, to deliver the court's judgment
Jerry Lampen, ANP/AFP

But La Paz has not specifically asked the court to rule directly on whether it has a right to access.

Santiago dismissed the case, saying the ICJ, set up in 1946 did not have jurisdiction to rule in the matter.

Chilean President Michelle Bachelet said Bolivia “had not won anything” with Thursday’s ruling.

The decision “does not affect our territorial integrity,” she said, adding the “only thing the court has so far decided is that is the apt tribunal to hear Bolivia’s request, without yet making any determination about the case.”

Chile says its territorial sovereignty was defined by treaties signed in 1904 and 1948 which prevent an international court from interfering in the matter and that today it was still governed by these treaties.

However, the treaties do not mention “Chile’s alleged obligation to negotiate Bolivia’s access” to the sea and therefore “Chile’s objection to jurisdiction… must accordingly be dismissed,” ICJ judge Ronny Abraham said.

Chilean president Michelle Bachelet speaks during a press conference at La Moneda Presidential Palac...

Chilean president Michelle Bachelet speaks during a press conference at La Moneda Presidential Palace in Santiago, on September 24, 2015
Ximena Navarro, Presidencia/AFP

Bolivia will also be encouraged by a judgement by the ICJ in January 2014 which gave Peru some of the maritime territory that had been under Chile’s control since the 19th century war.

Bolivian President Evo Morales on Thursday urged Santiago to open negotiations on the issue on learning of the court’s decision.

“We are a peaceful country, and I would like to …call on the government of Chile to accompany this process through dialogue,” Morales said from his official residence in La Paz.

But Bachelet shot back that Bolivia’s case “has no basis as it is confusing the law with aspirations and completely distorting the history between Chile and Bolivia.”

AFP
Written By

With 2,400 staff representing 100 different nationalities, AFP covers the world as a leading global news agency. AFP provides fast, comprehensive and verified coverage of the issues affecting our daily lives.

You may also like:

Business

Catherine Berthet (L) and Naoise Ryan (R) join relatives of people killed in the Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302 Boeing 737 MAX crash at a...

Business

Turkey's central bank holds its key interest rate steady at 50 percent - Copyright AFP MARCO BERTORELLOFulya OZERKANTurkey’s central bank held its key interest...

World

A vendor sweats as he pulls a vegetable cart at Bangkok's biggest fresh market, with people sweltering through heatwaves across Southeast and South Asia...

Tech & Science

Microsoft and Google drubbed quarterly earnings expectations.