Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

World

The tough task of predicting a Nobel literature laureate

-

Predicting a Nobel literature prize winner can be harder than finding a needle in a haystack, with hundreds of possible candidates but few clues as to who the chosen one will be.

Could Svetlana Alexievich of Belarus, Mircea Cartarescu of Romania or Joyce Carol Oates of the US -- to name but a few -- follow in the footsteps of last year's laureate Patrick Modiano?

The answer will only be known on Thursday when the Swedish Academy reveals its choice at 1:00 pm (1100 GMT).

For bookmakers, the lack of a clear frontrunner is good for business.

"The Nobel Prize in Literature is a bit mysterious. Everyone wants the prestige of having guessed the right name," said Jonas Nilsson, a spokesman for Unibet Sweden.

The real experts are usually reluctant to make a prediction.

"What is for sure is that the Swedish Academy likes to surprise," Gustav Kallstrand, a curator at the Nobel Museum said. Asked about the winner, his only response was to laugh.

"It is impossible to say who the winner will be this year. There are over a hundred possible authors, certainly even more," said Madelaine Levy, a literary critic at daily Svenska Dagbladet.

Many are putting their money on Belarusian journalist and writer Svetlana Alexievich to win the 2015...
Many are putting their money on Belarusian journalist and writer Svetlana Alexievich to win the 2015 Nobel prize for literature
Daniel Roland, AFP/File

The Academy, which never reveals the list of nominees, always sticks to the same timeline: In February, it lists all the nominations submitted by an exclusive group of "qualified people" that includes literature professors and former laureates.

By May, the list has been whittled down to five names, whose works Academy members study in detail during the summer. The winner is then traditionally announced in mid-October.

The opaque decision-making process leaves many basing their predictions on previous choices, where -- it is sometimes mentioned -- European names feature prominently.

- Intense speculation -

"Lately the Academy has tended to focus on authors exploring European identity after the Holocaust ... and also those who have delved into the impact of colonialism," said Bjorn Wiman, culture editor at daily Dagens Nyheter.

Levy said she didn't see this year's prize going to a Swede after Tomas Transtromer won in 2011, nor to a French author given last year's win for Patrick Modiano.

Mircea Cartarescu is Romania's most translated author and is rumoured to be among candidates fo...
Mircea Cartarescu is Romania's most translated author and is rumoured to be among candidates for the Nobel literature prize
Hendrik Schmidt, DPA/AFP/File

Another critic, Jens Liljestrand of the Expressen newspaper, said geography was not among the criteria considered by the Academy.

"It's not like when you pick the next host city for the Olympics and you say: This time it's Africa's turn," he said.

Still, many say now would be a good time to reward African literature by giving the prize to someone like Kenya's Ngugi wa Thiong'o, Somalia's Nuruddin Farah or Nigeria's Ben Okri.

Others believe it's high time for the award to go to an American author, which hasn't happened since Toni Morrison won in 1993.

"The Academy has shown an aversion towards American literature. ... I wouldn't protest if (Philip) Roth or Oates were given the prize," Wiman said.

In addition to geographical considerations, it has also been noted that the Academy, based in feminist Sweden, has only handed the award to women 13 out of 111 times since 1901.

"For a long time it helped to be a male, preferably older. The Academy didn't think about this being problematic. The gender inequality was obvious," Levy said.

"Over the past ten years the statistics, which are still not great, show a significant improvement ... which shows that they are now aware" of the problem, and that the jury "strives to make fairer choices," she added.

American science fiction writer Ursula Le Guin's name has appeared as a contender for the Nobel...
American science fiction writer Ursula Le Guin's name has appeared as a contender for the Nobel literature prize, but her genre has traditionally been shunned by the literary elite
Robin Marchant, Getty/AFP/File

Echoing those comments, Liljestrand said that "lately there has been a woman virtually every three years. They are more attentive."

Among punters, many are putting their money on Svetlana Alexievich, especially since "her work is on the border between documentary and novel, a genre that hasn't been rewarded," Wiman said.

Another woman whose name has appeared recently is American science fiction writer Ursula Le Guin. But that would be a surprise choice from the Academy, as the genre has traditionally been shunned by the literary elite.

"It would be exciting, but not really credible," said Liljestrand.

Predicting a Nobel literature prize winner can be harder than finding a needle in a haystack, with hundreds of possible candidates but few clues as to who the chosen one will be.

Could Svetlana Alexievich of Belarus, Mircea Cartarescu of Romania or Joyce Carol Oates of the US — to name but a few — follow in the footsteps of last year’s laureate Patrick Modiano?

The answer will only be known on Thursday when the Swedish Academy reveals its choice at 1:00 pm (1100 GMT).

For bookmakers, the lack of a clear frontrunner is good for business.

“The Nobel Prize in Literature is a bit mysterious. Everyone wants the prestige of having guessed the right name,” said Jonas Nilsson, a spokesman for Unibet Sweden.

The real experts are usually reluctant to make a prediction.

“What is for sure is that the Swedish Academy likes to surprise,” Gustav Kallstrand, a curator at the Nobel Museum said. Asked about the winner, his only response was to laugh.

“It is impossible to say who the winner will be this year. There are over a hundred possible authors, certainly even more,” said Madelaine Levy, a literary critic at daily Svenska Dagbladet.

Many are putting their money on Belarusian journalist and writer Svetlana Alexievich to win the 2015...

Many are putting their money on Belarusian journalist and writer Svetlana Alexievich to win the 2015 Nobel prize for literature
Daniel Roland, AFP/File

The Academy, which never reveals the list of nominees, always sticks to the same timeline: In February, it lists all the nominations submitted by an exclusive group of “qualified people” that includes literature professors and former laureates.

By May, the list has been whittled down to five names, whose works Academy members study in detail during the summer. The winner is then traditionally announced in mid-October.

The opaque decision-making process leaves many basing their predictions on previous choices, where — it is sometimes mentioned — European names feature prominently.

– Intense speculation –

“Lately the Academy has tended to focus on authors exploring European identity after the Holocaust … and also those who have delved into the impact of colonialism,” said Bjorn Wiman, culture editor at daily Dagens Nyheter.

Levy said she didn’t see this year’s prize going to a Swede after Tomas Transtromer won in 2011, nor to a French author given last year’s win for Patrick Modiano.

Mircea Cartarescu is Romania's most translated author and is rumoured to be among candidates fo...

Mircea Cartarescu is Romania's most translated author and is rumoured to be among candidates for the Nobel literature prize
Hendrik Schmidt, DPA/AFP/File

Another critic, Jens Liljestrand of the Expressen newspaper, said geography was not among the criteria considered by the Academy.

“It’s not like when you pick the next host city for the Olympics and you say: This time it’s Africa’s turn,” he said.

Still, many say now would be a good time to reward African literature by giving the prize to someone like Kenya’s Ngugi wa Thiong’o, Somalia’s Nuruddin Farah or Nigeria’s Ben Okri.

Others believe it’s high time for the award to go to an American author, which hasn’t happened since Toni Morrison won in 1993.

“The Academy has shown an aversion towards American literature. … I wouldn’t protest if (Philip) Roth or Oates were given the prize,” Wiman said.

In addition to geographical considerations, it has also been noted that the Academy, based in feminist Sweden, has only handed the award to women 13 out of 111 times since 1901.

“For a long time it helped to be a male, preferably older. The Academy didn’t think about this being problematic. The gender inequality was obvious,” Levy said.

“Over the past ten years the statistics, which are still not great, show a significant improvement … which shows that they are now aware” of the problem, and that the jury “strives to make fairer choices,” she added.

American science fiction writer Ursula Le Guin's name has appeared as a contender for the Nobel...

American science fiction writer Ursula Le Guin's name has appeared as a contender for the Nobel literature prize, but her genre has traditionally been shunned by the literary elite
Robin Marchant, Getty/AFP/File

Echoing those comments, Liljestrand said that “lately there has been a woman virtually every three years. They are more attentive.”

Among punters, many are putting their money on Svetlana Alexievich, especially since “her work is on the border between documentary and novel, a genre that hasn’t been rewarded,” Wiman said.

Another woman whose name has appeared recently is American science fiction writer Ursula Le Guin. But that would be a surprise choice from the Academy, as the genre has traditionally been shunned by the literary elite.

“It would be exciting, but not really credible,” said Liljestrand.

AFP
Written By

With 2,400 staff representing 100 different nationalities, AFP covers the world as a leading global news agency. AFP provides fast, comprehensive and verified coverage of the issues affecting our daily lives.

You may also like:

World

China on Friday proposed to host the secretariat of a new treaty governing the high seas.

Tech & Science

Extremophile microbes from hot springs may hold the secret to the next generation of natural, eco-friendly sunscreen.

World

Greenlanders are not panicking yet but they are thinking through what they would do if the worst were to happen.

Entertainment

Luana Seu, director, photographer and producer chatted about being a storyteller and creative in the digital age.