Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Tech & Science

Is Google deliberately degrading quality?

Has the quality of Google searches declined? Are users being fed too much paid content?

Google's advertising practices are also subject to investigations or proceedings in Britain, the EU and the United States
Google's advertising practices are also subject to investigations or proceedings in Britain, the EU and the United States. — © AFP/File Josh Edelson
Google's advertising practices are also subject to investigations or proceedings in Britain, the EU and the United States. — © AFP/File Josh Edelson

In light of Google facing the possibility of a court-mandated breakup after being found to be a monopoly, WalletHub’s CEO Odysseas Papadimitriou has told Digital Journal that, based on a recent analysis of search results and court documents, the deteriorating quality of Google search results over the last couple of years is most likely an intentional strategy designed to boost advertising revenue rather than poor execution.

To support his position, Papadimitriou cites:

Going Downhill: 63 percent of people think that Google search results were better last year, according to a nationally representative survey conducted by WalletHub.
 

Cost of Trusting Google’s Top 5 Results on Credit Cards & Banking Terms: $202 on average, according to a WalletHub study.
 

Industry insiders have been warning about this: The SEO industry has been up in arms about the declining quality of Google search.
 

Monopolies do not have to worry about quality: According to court documents (page 48 – section 134), Google’s internal testing showed that significantly worse search results would not hurt the business.

Why would Google act like this?

Poor quality is good for business

Deteriorating quality started after Google’s CEO put the head of Ads to lead both Search and Ads: Google always had a Church/State separation between their ad business and their organic search. In June 2020, Sundar Pichai decided to change that and align the two initiatives for maximum profit. Internal arguments prove that the separation was bad for consumers but good for advertising revenue.

For example, the former head of search wrote: “The nature of how you would easily increase queries is a key reason I don’t like queries as an end metric. The easy ways are almost all bad. Having queries as a metric will, in my opinion, have a subtly bad effect as a launch metric even if we ‘ decide not to do the bad things’.”

Papadimitriou continues to follow the matter closely and remains concerned about the impact on publishers as well as consumers.  

Avatar photo
Written By

Dr. Tim Sandle is Digital Journal's Editor-at-Large for science news. Tim specializes in science, technology, environmental, business, and health journalism. He is additionally a practising microbiologist; and an author. He is also interested in history, politics and current affairs.

You may also like:

Tech & Science

World leaders were set to hold formal talks in Paris on Tuesday on artificial intelligence (AI.

World

The White House posted a photo on social network X of cuffed and shackled people boarding a Venezuelan Conviasa plane.

World

A deluge of disinformation about a flu-like virus called HMPV is stoking anti-China sentiment across Asia.

Tech & Science

A new free app is helping Canadians verify whether the products they buy are made in Canada.