Facebook chief Mark Zuckerberg on Thursday sought to quell a new firestorm over the social network's handling of Russian misinformation efforts in 2016 and its hiring of a consulting firm that used questionable tactics to target the company's critics.
Speaking on a conference call on content moderation efforts, Zuckerberg repeated his comments that Facebook was slow to spot Russian interference in the 2016 election but argued that "to suggest we weren't interested in knowing the truth or that we wanted to hide what we knew or stop investigations is simply untrue."
Facebook said in an earlier statement that "we ended our contract" on Wednesday with Definers Public Affairs, a consultancy using campaign-style tactics and founded by Republican operatives that sought to link anti-Facebook campaigns to financier George Soros, according to the Times.
But Facebook disputed claims that it used the firm in a nefarious way.
The Times, Facebook said, was "wrong to suggest that we ever asked Definers to pay for or write articles on Facebook's behalf -- or to spread misinformation."
The Times said in its investigation that Definers had sought to cast billionaire liberal donor Soros as the "unacknowledged force" behind a broad anti-Facebook movement.
- Taking on Facebook critics -
Facebook acknowledged that Definers had encouraged reporters to look into the funding of "Freedom from Facebook," an anti-Facebook organization.
"The intention was to demonstrate that it was not simply a spontaneous grassroots campaign, as it claimed, but supported by a well-known critic of our company," it said in a statement, without naming Soros.
But it added that to suggest "that this was an anti-Semitic attack is reprehensible and untrue."
Zuckerberg said he was not aware of the role of the firm and learned about it from the Times article.
"I got on the phone with our team and we are no longer working with this firm," he told journalists.
"This type of firm might be normal in Washington but it is not the kind of thing I want Facebook associated with."
While the Times noted that Soros was a favorite bete noire of anti-Semites, it did not characterize the actions of Facebook or Definers as anti-Semitic.
- Board backs Zuckerberg -
The board of directors issued a statement backing the efforts of Zuckerberg and chief operating officer Sheryl Sandberg in responding to influence campaigns.
"As Mark and Sheryl made clear to Congress, the company was too slow to spot Russian interference, and too slow to take action. As a board we did indeed push them to move faster," the board statement said.
"But to suggest that they knew about Russian interference and either tried to ignore it or prevent investigations into what had happened is grossly unfair."
The Times said Facebook had amassed evidence for over a year of Russian activity through an investigation led by its former security chief, Alex Stamos.
Stamos, who is now a Stanford University faculty member, said his probe did find a link to Russia in the first half of 2016 but that his investigation was not quashed.
"The entire discussion around Facebook's disclosures of what happened in 2016 is very frustrating. No exec stopped any investigations, but there were a lot of heated discussions about what to publish and when," Stamos said on Twitter.
"A lot of parties failed in 2016. I failed to prepare my employer for the disinformation campaign and that is on me."
- Going on the attack -
The Times said that when criticism of its belated Russia admission grew, Facebook mounted a lobbying campaign led by Sandberg, pushing negative stories about its political critics and making rival companies like Google and Apple look bad.
In July of this year, as a Facebook executive testified before a congressional committee, anti-Facebook demonstrators barged into the room and held up a sign depicting chief executive Mark Zuckerberg and Sandberg -- who are both Jewish -- as the twin heads of an octopus with its tentacles around the world.
Facebook responded by lobbying a Jewish civil rights group -- the Anti-Defamation League -- to publicly label that criticism as anti-Semitic, the Times said.
The Open Society Foundation founded by Soros meanwhile called for an independent probe of Facebook's tactics.
"We urge Facebook to stop engaging in practices inspired by the enemies of democracy across the globe," said a statement from foundation president Patrick Gaspard.
"Facebook should launch an independent investigation of what took place and to publish a full report disclosing the techniques that were used in their effort to compromise activists and George Soros."
The world's most popular social media platform has been on the back foot for months, including over the allegation that data from millions of Facebook users was abused by the consultancy Cambridge Analytica to help drive Donald Trump to the White House.
At the same time, Facebook and other tech giants are facing criticism from Trump and others that they suppress conservative voices.
Facebook chief Mark Zuckerberg on Thursday sought to quell a new firestorm over the social network’s handling of Russian misinformation efforts in 2016 and its hiring of a consulting firm that used questionable tactics to target the company’s critics.
Speaking on a conference call on content moderation efforts, Zuckerberg repeated his comments that Facebook was slow to spot Russian interference in the 2016 election but argued that “to suggest we weren’t interested in knowing the truth or that we wanted to hide what we knew or stop investigations is simply untrue.”
Facebook said in an earlier statement that “we ended our contract” on Wednesday with Definers Public Affairs, a consultancy using campaign-style tactics and founded by Republican operatives that sought to link anti-Facebook campaigns to financier George Soros, according to the Times.
But Facebook disputed claims that it used the firm in a nefarious way.
The Times, Facebook said, was “wrong to suggest that we ever asked Definers to pay for or write articles on Facebook’s behalf — or to spread misinformation.”
The Times said in its investigation that Definers had sought to cast billionaire liberal donor Soros as the “unacknowledged force” behind a broad anti-Facebook movement.
– Taking on Facebook critics –
Facebook acknowledged that Definers had encouraged reporters to look into the funding of “Freedom from Facebook,” an anti-Facebook organization.
“The intention was to demonstrate that it was not simply a spontaneous grassroots campaign, as it claimed, but supported by a well-known critic of our company,” it said in a statement, without naming Soros.
But it added that to suggest “that this was an anti-Semitic attack is reprehensible and untrue.”
Zuckerberg said he was not aware of the role of the firm and learned about it from the Times article.
“I got on the phone with our team and we are no longer working with this firm,” he told journalists.
“This type of firm might be normal in Washington but it is not the kind of thing I want Facebook associated with.”
While the Times noted that Soros was a favorite bete noire of anti-Semites, it did not characterize the actions of Facebook or Definers as anti-Semitic.
– Board backs Zuckerberg –
The board of directors issued a statement backing the efforts of Zuckerberg and chief operating officer Sheryl Sandberg in responding to influence campaigns.
“As Mark and Sheryl made clear to Congress, the company was too slow to spot Russian interference, and too slow to take action. As a board we did indeed push them to move faster,” the board statement said.
“But to suggest that they knew about Russian interference and either tried to ignore it or prevent investigations into what had happened is grossly unfair.”
The Times said Facebook had amassed evidence for over a year of Russian activity through an investigation led by its former security chief, Alex Stamos.
Stamos, who is now a Stanford University faculty member, said his probe did find a link to Russia in the first half of 2016 but that his investigation was not quashed.
“The entire discussion around Facebook’s disclosures of what happened in 2016 is very frustrating. No exec stopped any investigations, but there were a lot of heated discussions about what to publish and when,” Stamos said on Twitter.
“A lot of parties failed in 2016. I failed to prepare my employer for the disinformation campaign and that is on me.”
– Going on the attack –
The Times said that when criticism of its belated Russia admission grew, Facebook mounted a lobbying campaign led by Sandberg, pushing negative stories about its political critics and making rival companies like Google and Apple look bad.
In July of this year, as a Facebook executive testified before a congressional committee, anti-Facebook demonstrators barged into the room and held up a sign depicting chief executive Mark Zuckerberg and Sandberg — who are both Jewish — as the twin heads of an octopus with its tentacles around the world.
Facebook responded by lobbying a Jewish civil rights group — the Anti-Defamation League — to publicly label that criticism as anti-Semitic, the Times said.
The Open Society Foundation founded by Soros meanwhile called for an independent probe of Facebook’s tactics.
“We urge Facebook to stop engaging in practices inspired by the enemies of democracy across the globe,” said a statement from foundation president Patrick Gaspard.
“Facebook should launch an independent investigation of what took place and to publish a full report disclosing the techniques that were used in their effort to compromise activists and George Soros.”
The world’s most popular social media platform has been on the back foot for months, including over the allegation that data from millions of Facebook users was abused by the consultancy Cambridge Analytica to help drive Donald Trump to the White House.
At the same time, Facebook and other tech giants are facing criticism from Trump and others that they suppress conservative voices.
