Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

World

Europe needs more ‘rational’ discussion on migrants: UN refugee chief

-

Attitudes towards migrants in Europe "are more emotional than rational", with denial about the realities of migration helping fuel the current crisis, the head of the UN's refugee agency, Antonio Guterres, said Thursday.

In an interview with AFP, Guterres raised further alarm about the scale of the migrant crisis, calling for a Europe-wide response, "as no country can solve it by itself."

But he said efforts to forge a unified approach to the problem have been undermined by public attitudes that are, at times, irrationally anti-immigrant.

"I think that the discussions about migration in Europe are discussions that are more emotional than rational," Guterres said at the UNHCR headquarters in Geneva.

"Migration is part of the solution to European problems," he said, pointing to the low fertility rates affecting most European countries and the fact that immigrants often do jobs that local people don't want.

Rather than trying to manage the surge of migrants and refugees in a way that recognises the needs of European societies, "we have a situation of denial," Guterres told AFP.

UN High Commissioner for Refugees Antonio Guterres speaking at the United Nations Office at Geneva
UN High Commissioner for Refugees Antonio Guterres speaking at the United Nations Office at Geneva
Fabrice Coffrini, AFP/File

"Those that benefit from the situation of denial are the smugglers and traffickers."

According to the UN, nearly 260,000 thousand migrants have washed up on European shores already this year, typically after a perilous journey across the Mediterranean orchestrated by traffickers.

The scale of the movement of people, most of whom are refugees fleeing conflicts in Africa and the Middle East, is unprecedented since World War II.

"What we are now witnessing is a staggering escalation with no parallel in the recent past," Guterres said, warning that in light of the large number of violent crises in the world, including Syria, "we can expect that in the near future the numbers will tend to rise."

- 'Not doing their job' -

Guterres hailed the largely effective management of asylum seekers in Sweden and Germany, saying it was no coincidence that about half of all asylum requests in Europe are made in those two countries.

"In Europe, we need to recognise that some countries are doing an excellent job... but there are other countries that are not doing their job," he said.

He said it was clear that Greece, plagued by financial crisis, did not have the capacity to cope with the massive influx of arrivals, numbering more than 160,000 already this year.

Some eastern European countries have responded poorly, "because they have no tradition in relation to asylum," Guterres said.

He condemned an announcement by Slovakia's interior ministry on Thursday that the country was willing to take in 200 Syrian refugees, but only if they were Christians.

"Resettlement is something that needs to be done based on vulnerability, but without any, any discrimination (on the basis)of religion," Guterres said.

The UN refugee chief had earlier hailed a deal agreed by Britain and France to tackle people smuggling and improve humanitarian conditions for the thousands of people living in slum-like conditions in the French port city of Calais.

But, he said in an earlier statement, increasing "legal avenues" to enter Europe was key to any solution on human trafficking.

Attitudes towards migrants in Europe “are more emotional than rational”, with denial about the realities of migration helping fuel the current crisis, the head of the UN’s refugee agency, Antonio Guterres, said Thursday.

In an interview with AFP, Guterres raised further alarm about the scale of the migrant crisis, calling for a Europe-wide response, “as no country can solve it by itself.”

But he said efforts to forge a unified approach to the problem have been undermined by public attitudes that are, at times, irrationally anti-immigrant.

“I think that the discussions about migration in Europe are discussions that are more emotional than rational,” Guterres said at the UNHCR headquarters in Geneva.

“Migration is part of the solution to European problems,” he said, pointing to the low fertility rates affecting most European countries and the fact that immigrants often do jobs that local people don’t want.

Rather than trying to manage the surge of migrants and refugees in a way that recognises the needs of European societies, “we have a situation of denial,” Guterres told AFP.

UN High Commissioner for Refugees Antonio Guterres speaking at the United Nations Office at Geneva

UN High Commissioner for Refugees Antonio Guterres speaking at the United Nations Office at Geneva
Fabrice Coffrini, AFP/File

“Those that benefit from the situation of denial are the smugglers and traffickers.”

According to the UN, nearly 260,000 thousand migrants have washed up on European shores already this year, typically after a perilous journey across the Mediterranean orchestrated by traffickers.

The scale of the movement of people, most of whom are refugees fleeing conflicts in Africa and the Middle East, is unprecedented since World War II.

“What we are now witnessing is a staggering escalation with no parallel in the recent past,” Guterres said, warning that in light of the large number of violent crises in the world, including Syria, “we can expect that in the near future the numbers will tend to rise.”

– ‘Not doing their job’ –

Guterres hailed the largely effective management of asylum seekers in Sweden and Germany, saying it was no coincidence that about half of all asylum requests in Europe are made in those two countries.

“In Europe, we need to recognise that some countries are doing an excellent job… but there are other countries that are not doing their job,” he said.

He said it was clear that Greece, plagued by financial crisis, did not have the capacity to cope with the massive influx of arrivals, numbering more than 160,000 already this year.

Some eastern European countries have responded poorly, “because they have no tradition in relation to asylum,” Guterres said.

He condemned an announcement by Slovakia’s interior ministry on Thursday that the country was willing to take in 200 Syrian refugees, but only if they were Christians.

“Resettlement is something that needs to be done based on vulnerability, but without any, any discrimination (on the basis)of religion,” Guterres said.

The UN refugee chief had earlier hailed a deal agreed by Britain and France to tackle people smuggling and improve humanitarian conditions for the thousands of people living in slum-like conditions in the French port city of Calais.

But, he said in an earlier statement, increasing “legal avenues” to enter Europe was key to any solution on human trafficking.

AFP
Written By

With 2,400 staff representing 100 different nationalities, AFP covers the world as a leading global news agency. AFP provides fast, comprehensive and verified coverage of the issues affecting our daily lives.

You may also like:

World

Stop pretending to know what you’re talking about. You’re wrong and you know you’re wrong. So does everyone else.

Social Media

The US House of Representatives will again vote Saturday on a bill that would force TikTok to divest from Chinese parent company ByteDance.

Entertainment

Taylor Swift is primed to release her highly anticipated record "The Tortured Poets Department" on Friday.

Business

Two sons of the world's richest man Bernard Arnault on Thursday joined the board of LVMH after a shareholder vote.