Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

World

Caste crisis: Why do quotas still exist in modern India?

-

Rioting and arson over demands for caste quotas has left 10 people dead in a north Indian state and seen thousands of troops deployed.

Here are key questions about India's caste system:

- Who is behind the violence?

The Jat caste are the single biggest community in Haryana state bordering New Delhi, with nearly eight million members, and large communities also in neighbouring states.

A traditionally rural group, many are farmers who have suffered in recent years from falling crop prices and drought.

They are not the only group to launch such action. The relatively well-off Patel caste of traders and farmers staged violent protests last year in the western state of Gujarat.

- What do they want?

Protesters run along a street during violence after rival caste groups clashed during a mass rally o...
Protesters run along a street during violence after rival caste groups clashed during a mass rally over access to jobs and education in Rohtak, northern India on February 19, 2016
, AFP

They want a quota of government jobs and university places reserved for Jats. Such quotas are given to India's many socially disadvantaged groups, including the lowest Dalit caste formerly known as "untouchables".

Jats in Haryana are demanding they be officially included in "other backward classes". This would guarantee them sought-after jobs in the public service and places at colleges.

- Why is the violence happening now?

Jat leaders have been threatening for months to launch protests, but Haryana's ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government seems to have been taken by surprise by the violence.

The Haryana government agreed last year to grant 10 percent reservation to Jats, according to local media reports. But the High Court in July stayed that decision. Tension has been brewing ever since.

Burnt-out buses and fire damage to buildings are pictured at a school in the northern Indian city of...
Burnt-out buses and fire damage to buildings are pictured at a school in the northern Indian city of Rohtak on February 21, 2016 following violent caste protests
Sajjad Hussain, AFP

Nationally, Jats have been fuming since the Supreme Court last year struck down the previous central government's decision to allot quotas to their caste.

The court said the decision would exceed the legal maximum of 50 percent reserved quotas for public service jobs and college places.

- Why does modern India even still have castes?

The hierarchical system is seen by many as an ancient form of discrimination that has no place in modern India, whose economy has been growing rapidly.

Caste restrictions, which stopped the "untouchable" Dalits and other lower groups from advancing, have eased dramatically over the years. Narendra Modi, the son of a tea-seller who rose to become prime minister, is proof of that.

But discrimination against low castes is still rife in underdeveloped, uneducated and rural areas where more than half the population lives.

- Why are caste quotas still important?

Caste-based quotas are meant to provide equal opportunities for India's poorest and most marginalised groups. Nearly one in four Indians still lives on less than $1.25 a day.

A pedestrian walks past a burnt-out bus following violent caste protests in the northern Indian city...
A pedestrian walks past a burnt-out bus following violent caste protests in the northern Indian city of Rohtak on February 21, 2016
Sajjad Hussain, AFP

Public-sector jobs are highly sought after because they are seen as extremely secure. Thousands of people, including qualified professionals, regularly apply for even the most menial posts.

With India's population set to overtake China's within a decade, the country faces major unemployment problems and competition for such posts will continue to be fierce.

The system is the subject of frequent challenges, with the number of places allocated to disadvantaged groups changing from state to state.

Politicians often promise to scale back the quota system, or to include a particular caste demanding inclusion, in order to win votes.

Rioting and arson over demands for caste quotas has left 10 people dead in a north Indian state and seen thousands of troops deployed.

Here are key questions about India’s caste system:

– Who is behind the violence?

The Jat caste are the single biggest community in Haryana state bordering New Delhi, with nearly eight million members, and large communities also in neighbouring states.

A traditionally rural group, many are farmers who have suffered in recent years from falling crop prices and drought.

They are not the only group to launch such action. The relatively well-off Patel caste of traders and farmers staged violent protests last year in the western state of Gujarat.

– What do they want?

Protesters run along a street during violence after rival caste groups clashed during a mass rally o...

Protesters run along a street during violence after rival caste groups clashed during a mass rally over access to jobs and education in Rohtak, northern India on February 19, 2016
, AFP

They want a quota of government jobs and university places reserved for Jats. Such quotas are given to India’s many socially disadvantaged groups, including the lowest Dalit caste formerly known as “untouchables”.

Jats in Haryana are demanding they be officially included in “other backward classes”. This would guarantee them sought-after jobs in the public service and places at colleges.

– Why is the violence happening now?

Jat leaders have been threatening for months to launch protests, but Haryana’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government seems to have been taken by surprise by the violence.

The Haryana government agreed last year to grant 10 percent reservation to Jats, according to local media reports. But the High Court in July stayed that decision. Tension has been brewing ever since.

Burnt-out buses and fire damage to buildings are pictured at a school in the northern Indian city of...

Burnt-out buses and fire damage to buildings are pictured at a school in the northern Indian city of Rohtak on February 21, 2016 following violent caste protests
Sajjad Hussain, AFP

Nationally, Jats have been fuming since the Supreme Court last year struck down the previous central government’s decision to allot quotas to their caste.

The court said the decision would exceed the legal maximum of 50 percent reserved quotas for public service jobs and college places.

– Why does modern India even still have castes?

The hierarchical system is seen by many as an ancient form of discrimination that has no place in modern India, whose economy has been growing rapidly.

Caste restrictions, which stopped the “untouchable” Dalits and other lower groups from advancing, have eased dramatically over the years. Narendra Modi, the son of a tea-seller who rose to become prime minister, is proof of that.

But discrimination against low castes is still rife in underdeveloped, uneducated and rural areas where more than half the population lives.

– Why are caste quotas still important?

Caste-based quotas are meant to provide equal opportunities for India’s poorest and most marginalised groups. Nearly one in four Indians still lives on less than $1.25 a day.

A pedestrian walks past a burnt-out bus following violent caste protests in the northern Indian city...

A pedestrian walks past a burnt-out bus following violent caste protests in the northern Indian city of Rohtak on February 21, 2016
Sajjad Hussain, AFP

Public-sector jobs are highly sought after because they are seen as extremely secure. Thousands of people, including qualified professionals, regularly apply for even the most menial posts.

With India’s population set to overtake China’s within a decade, the country faces major unemployment problems and competition for such posts will continue to be fierce.

The system is the subject of frequent challenges, with the number of places allocated to disadvantaged groups changing from state to state.

Politicians often promise to scale back the quota system, or to include a particular caste demanding inclusion, in order to win votes.

AFP
Written By

With 2,400 staff representing 100 different nationalities, AFP covers the world as a leading global news agency. AFP provides fast, comprehensive and verified coverage of the issues affecting our daily lives.

You may also like:

World

Let’s just hope sanity finally gets a word in edgewise.

Business

Two sons of the world's richest man Bernard Arnault on Thursday joined the board of LVMH after a shareholder vote.

Entertainment

Taylor Swift is primed to release her highly anticipated record "The Tortured Poets Department" on Friday.

Tech & Science

The role of AI regulation should be to facilitate innovation.