The Power of Citizen Journalism
 
News» Top News» Latest News» Post News ($) Blogs» Top Blogs» Latest Blogs» Post Blog» Images» Top Images» Latest Images» Upload Images» TV» Groups» View Groups» Create a Group» Live Events» Alerts» Create an Alert» Manage Alerts» How do I ...» Get paid to report news» Post blogs» Upload images» Embed video» Join/create groups» Vote on news & images» Comment & debate»
 

article imageDrinking Iced Tea May Increase Risk of Developing Kidney Stones

Posted Jul 22, 2008 by  Bob Ewing in Health | 15 comments | 2037 views
Join our team to voice opinions, share images, get paid to report news and more!
Email Print Share
Subscribe to author

Email this article

Recipient email:
Your email:
optional
Message:
optional
What can be better than a tall cold glass of ice tea on a hot summer day? Think twice before downing the drink because you may develop kidney stones due to the drink's high concentration of a chemical that causes stones.
Once he was an "avid lover" of iced tea, downing up to six glasses a day of the popular summertime thirst-quencher.

"I was a junkie on a bender. I had to have it every day," said Mark Mulac, a resident of Brookfield, Ill. "Iced tea was very refreshing, cheap to buy and easy to make."

Mulac has had to give up his favourite summer beverage because Iced tea helped bring on an excruciating bout of kidney stones that led to surgery at Loyola University Hospital in Maywood, Ill.

"The pain was so bad that once it felt like I was delivering a child made out of razor blades," said the 46-year-old Mulac. "I really had no idea that iced tea could lead to that."

What happened? Iced tea contains high concentrations of oxalate, one of the key chemicals that lead to the formation of kidney stones, a common disorder of the urinary tract that affects about 10 percent of the population in the United States.

"For many people, iced tea is potentially one of the worst things they can drink," said Dr. John Milner, instructor, department of urology, Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine, Maywood, Ill. "For people who have a tendency to form kidney stones, it's definitely one of the worst things you can drink."

Kidney stones are crystals that form in the kidneys or ureters, the small tubes that drain the urine from the kidney to the bladder. Men are four times more likely to develop kidney stones than women, and their risk rises dramatically once they reach their 40s.

The failure to drink enough fluids is the most common cause of kidney stones. In the summer, when the weather is hot, people are generally more dehydrated due to sweating. The dehydration combined with increase iced tea consumption raises the risk of kidney stones, especially in people who are prone to develop them.

"People are told that in the summertime they should drink more fluids," said Milner, who treated Mulac's kidney stones. "A lot of people choose to drink more iced tea, thinking it's a tastier alternative. However, in terms of kidney stones, they’re getting it going and coming. They're actually doing themselves a disservice."

The popularity of iced tea has grown dramatically with a whopping 1.91 billion gallons consumed a year in the U.S., according to the Tea Association of the U.S.A. Nearly 128 Americans drink the beverage daily.

Iced tea's appeal is due to the belief that it is healthier than other beverages such as soda and beer.

"I stayed away from carbonated drinks for a long time because I thought it was upsetting my stomach and that it wasn't as good for me, but I guess overdid it with the iced tea," Mulac said.

Water is your best bet when you want to quench your summer thirst. You can always add lemon slices for some extra flavour.

"Lemons are very high in citrates, which inhibit the growth of kidney stones," Milner said. "Lemonade, not the powdered variety that uses artificial flavoring, actually slows the development of kidney stones for those who are prone to the development of kidney stones."

People concerned about developing kidney stones should cut back on eating foods that also contain high concentrations of oxalates such as spinach, chocolate, rhubarb and nuts.

Also, go easy on salt, eat meat sparingly, drink several glasses a water a day and don’t avoid foods high in calcium, which reduces the amount of oxalate the body absorbs.
article:257714:15::0
4 subscribers
Subscribe to this thread
  • avatar Posted Jul 22, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #1
    This smells like a hoax, launched by the iced tea competition. If iced tea has a high concentration of oxalates, all teas do. The very idea seems laughable. There are far far more oxalates in spinach, rhubarb and any number of green leafy vegetables.

    Good thing they advise people to drink fluids. Their lives would be horrible if they were to drink solids.
  • avatar Posted Jul 22, 2008 by  Cynthia T. [Picasso]
    #2
    @ Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    This smells like a hoax, launched by the iced tea competition. If iced tea has a high concentration of oxalates, all teas do. The very idea seems laughable. There are far far more oxalates in spinach, rhubarb and any number of green leafy vegetables.

    Good thing they advise people to drink fluids. Their lives would be horrible if they were to drink solids.


    LOL. Hey good to see you Bart I was thinking about you yesterday and wondering where you have been.

    I like iced tea but also drink a lot of water.
  • avatar Posted Jul 22, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #3
    Good to see you as well, Cynthia.
  • avatar Posted Jul 22, 2008 by  Bob Ewing
    #4
    An iced tea conspiracy, movie coming soon.
  • avatar Posted Jul 22, 2008 by  Bob Ewing
    #5
    so is Loyola University Health System in on this alleged hoax?
  • avatar Posted Jul 23, 2008 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #6
    I like iced tea, but not that much! I already from problems with gall stones, so I wouldn't want to tempt fate twice in a row! LOL!

    Hi ya, Bart! Good to see you again!
  • avatar Posted Jul 23, 2008 by  Bob Ewing
    #7
    I do now and then drink iced tea and will continue to do so, make my own with the mint in the backyard.
  • avatar Posted Jul 31, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #8
    @ Bob Ewing
    so is Loyola University Health System in on this alleged hoax?
    The reason it smells like a hoax, is the emphasis on iced tea. There is, to the best of my knowledge, no difference between iced tea and freshly brewed tea. The only difference is the temperature.
  • avatar Posted Jul 31, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #9
    @ Debra Myers (skyangel)
    I like iced tea, but not that much! I already from problems with gall stones, so I wouldn't want to tempt fate twice in a row! LOL!

    Hi ya, Bart! Good to see you again!
    Good to see you, Debra.
  • avatar Posted Jul 31, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #10
    @ Bob Ewing
    I do now and then drink iced tea and will continue to do so, make my own with the mint in the backyard.
    And right you are.
  • avatar Posted Jul 31, 2008 by  Bob Ewing
    #11
    @ Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    The reason it smells like a hoax, is the emphasis on iced tea. There is, to the best of my knowledge, no difference between iced tea and freshly brewed tea. The only difference is the temperature.
    If the iced tea is made from tea and not a mix or bottled with extras, this is the case.
  • avatar Posted Jul 31, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #12
    @ Bob Ewing
    If the iced tea is made from tea and not a mix or bottled with extras, this is the case.
    Exactly. And the truth is that Iced tea *is* made from tea. Tea contains so very little that it can be seen as contaminated water. Oxalates are a minuscule portion of that contamination. In other words, one actually has to eat tea leaves in order to get an appreciable intake of oxalates. And even then, tea leaves are essentially harmless. Tea leaves are indeed cooked and eaten in certain cuisines. Rhubarb leaves contain far more oxalates. They are not eaten, for they can cause death because of their oxalate concentration.
  • avatar Posted Aug 1, 2008 by  Bob Ewing
    #13
    Bart, powdered ice tea in addition to tea, may contain artificial sweeteners and citric acid and possibly other ingredients, the same can apply to bottled ice teas and bottled green ice teas, so these products which people consume are not just tea.
  • avatar Posted Aug 1, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #14
    @ Bob Ewing
    Bart, powdered ice tea in addition to tea, may contain artificial sweeteners and citric acid and possibly other ingredients, the same can apply to bottled ice teas and bottled green ice teas, so these products which people consume are not just tea.
    That is true, Bob, but those are also added to hot tea, and they are therefore irrelevant for this story. On top of that, the story was about oxalates, and there is not a single manufacturer who would be foolish enough to add these to a product.

    My point remains that the story emphasizes iced tea, and that this unnecessarily demonizes iced tea. I would have been a little bit less emphatic if they had simply talked about tea. Many people have been convinced by marketers that tea is some type of a miracle health product, whereas the truth is that nobody has ever been able to prove any health benefits whatsoever. Sure, there is the occasional "study" that claims to show health benefits, but all these studies have at least one enormous flaw: at best, they show some type of correlation between tea and health, but it is the same type of correlation as that between the number of legs of a flea and its hearing abilities: remove all the legs from a flea, and it will no longer respond to the command to jump, a well-known cautionary tale in scientific circles.

    Let me also add that citric acid is nothing more than one of the acids found in lemons (and many other plants), it is not the "dangerous chemical" many people believe it is.
  • avatar Posted Aug 1, 2008 by  Bob Ewing
    #15
    That is true, Bob, but those are also added to hot tea,
    tI disagree, what I feel is the real flaw in the study is to make it clear the source of the ice tea, was it made at home by first making a tea and then chilling it and serving it with ice and adding lemon or lime for flavouring or was it a tea made from a mix or purchased in a bottle with artificial sweeteners added. I know what citric acid is but the fact that it is in the tea may mean it contributes to the problem.
    So if the iced tea the particpants were drinking was made from a tea not and herbal infusion but a tea, chilled and served then you may have a point.

    the lack of clarity in the study is the real fault.

Add a Comment

You have to Login or Register to comment


Email:
Password:
Remember meForgot password?