The Power of Citizen Journalism
Post News ($)»     Post Blog»     Upload Image»     Groups»     Events»     Alerts»     How do I ...»
Email Print Share

Email this article

Recipient email:
Your email:
optional
Message:
optional

Publisher Recalls Book: Memoirs Of Los Angeles Gang Survival Prove Fabricated

Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Nikki W (karateblossom) in Entertainment | 11 comments | 364 views
Next in Entertainment
Related News
Advertising
Riverhead Books has recalled all copies of "Love and Consequences", a young woman's memoir of gang life and survival on the streets of Los Angeles, California. The book was published last week.
Just how TRUE are those memoirs sitting on local bookstore shelves? In light of last week’s scandal involving Misha: A Memoire of the Holocaust Years by Misha Defonseca and the fabrication of content made public over Oprah’s book club selection entitled A Million Little Pieces by James Frey, a new “story” of sorts is being pulled from publication.

Love and Consequences, a true story of a young woman’s survival of gang life on the streets of Los Angeles, California has turned out to be a total fabrication of events. Consequently, publishers have recalled all copies of the book and are offering refunds.

A recent report tells of Margaret Seltzer’s, or more commonly known as memoir author Margaret B. Jones, intent to defraud readers by knowingly taking information from real gang members and writing and selling them as her own.

In her book, Seltzer talks about how she, as “Margaret Jones”, was raised, as a white girl, by a black foster family in a poverty-stricken gang neighborhood of South Los Angeles. Her stories of survival through illegal activities in support of the violent gang known as the Bloods, as well as witnessing the murder of her own foster brother by rival gang, the Crips, was all just fictional writing.

In reality, her biological family raised Margaret Seltzer, a 33-year-old Oregon resident, in a wealthy San Fernando Valley, California area, where she attended a private religious school.

Seltzer wrote her faux-memoirs while performing outreach work to gang members in the Los Angeles area.

The million-dollar question: How did her little lie come to be known?

It wasn’t a burning sense of remorse on Margaret’s part that brought her secret to light. Her sister, Cyndi Hoffman, stumbled upon an article in the New York Times about the author of the memoirs and contacted the publisher, questioning their fact-checking methods on the content of the author's story: her younger sister.

Call it fate; call it destiny; call it meant to be. The book is being recalled, as this woman deceived a lot of readers with fabrications, lies and by stealing the stories of real victims. She abused the system for her own perception of glory. In her defense, Margaret Seltzer states:

……I thought it was my opportunity to put a voice to people who people don't listen to,”……

Who will be listening now, Margaret Seltzer? Who will be listening now?

Related Story
article:251256:11::0
4 subscribers
Subscribe To This Thread[?] :
  • avatar Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Pamela Jean (GotTheScoop)
    #1
    This is ridiculous and just shows the moral decay of our society. Why this woman didn't just write a fictional portrayal of the things she had witnessed and the stories others had shared with her is beyond me.

    She was just a liar - pure and simple. This also shows the lack of background checking and verification on the part of the publisher.

    The story, however, is not surprising. I think there is alot of BS that is "spun" as factual in this world we live in.
  • avatar Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Nikki W (karateblossom)
    #2
    @ Pamela Jean (GotTheScoop)
    This is ridiculous and just shows the moral decay of our society. Why this woman didn't just write a fictional portrayal of the things she had witnessed and the stories others had shared with her is beyond me.

    She was just a liar - pure and simple. This also shows the lack of background checking and verification on the part of the publisher.

    The story, however, is not surprising. I think there is alot of BS that is "spun" as factual in this world we live in.


    It really bothered me and made me second guess anything I have read as memoirs, aside from medically and peer reviewed (credible sources) sources.

    I find it INCREDIBLY AMAZING that her sister happened upon an NYT article and question the author's credibility - unknowingly that the author was her own sister is how I understood it. Karma, man, Karma. :-)
  • avatar Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Helena Handbasket
    #3
    Now see -- with thorough, check, double-check, triple-check vetting of the story this contrived offering posing as fact would never see publication.

    As Pam observes -- moral decay. Create a life story and sell it as truth.

    Good article blossom.
  • avatar Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Nikki W (karateblossom)
    #4
    @ Helena Handbasket
    Now see -- with thorough, check, double-check, triple-check vetting of the story this contrived offering posing as fact would never see publication.

    As Pam observes -- moral decay. Create a life story and sell it as truth.

    Good article blossom.


    Thanks Helena....funny you call me "blossom" - tis my real nickname! :o)
  • avatar Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Chris V. (cgull)
    #5
    There was a similar story in Oprah's show, he claimed it was his story and later they found out it was fake like this one. This just happened few months ago, as if she didn't know about that one.
  • avatar Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Susan Duclos
    #6
    Awesome piece and a very good find.
  • avatar Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Bob Ewing
    #7
    She could have written a creative non-fiction piece based upon
    performing outreach work to gang members in the Los Angeles area.
    but she choose the lie. this is just wrong. Good work KB
  • avatar Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Nikki W (karateblossom)
    #8
    @ Bob Ewing
    She could have written a creative non-fiction piece based upon but she choose the lie. this is just wrong. Good work KB


    Thank you. I don't think her intentions were as innocent as she claims.....the monies for her "personal" story were probably more than a truly humanitarian effort. She must deal with the consequences now.
  • avatar Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #9
    My thought as I read this is why didn't she just publish it as a work of fiction instead of passing it off as memoirs. Now, no one is ever going to believe a word she writes...
  • avatar Posted Mar 5, 2008 by  Nikki W (karateblossom)
    #10
    @ Debra Myers (skyangel)
    My thought as I read this is why didn't she just publish it as a work of fiction instead of passing it off as memoirs. Now, no one is ever going to believe a word she writes...


    Karma
  • avatar Posted Mar 6, 2008 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #11
    @ Nikki W (karateblossom)
    Karma


    Indeed!

Add a Comment

You have to Login or Register to comment


Email:
Password:
Remember meForgot password?