The Power of Citizen Journalism
Post News ($)»     Post Blog»     Upload Image»     Groups»     Events»     Alerts»     How do I ...»
Email Print Share

Email this article

Recipient email:
Your email:
optional
Message:
optional

article imageOp-Ed: Robots Among Us

Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Ringwraith in Technology | 26 comments | 858 views
Next in Technology
Related News
Advertising
When you think about the future, do you see robots performing everyday household chores, acting as soldiers in war and taking care of the elderly? What was once science fiction is quickly becoming the reality of today.
I was watching an episode of the Agenda, which featured an interview with science fiction writer Robert J. Sawyer discussing his new book Rollback, and became inspired by his words about the growing role of robots in our society, envisioning a not-so-distant future where they are part of our everyday lives.

In the News

One does not need to search very far to find evidence of robots everywhere in our daily lives and if you want proof, just do a quick search in Digital Journal to see the variety of stories touching on the inspiring and also the bizarre.

An excellent example of the changes in modern human psyche when it comes to our relationship with robots and the embracing of technology is a provocative report by Bart B. Van Bockstaele on David Levy's thesis “Intimate relationships with artificial partners.”

Twendy-One is a robot that speaks and helps out around the house. - Photo courtesy twendyone.com


A highly sophisticated robot from Japan, named Twendy-One, is described in an article by cgull. Designed to help take care of the elderly, it is capable of assisting a person out of bed, chatting with them as well as preparing and serving meals.



With an aging population, and a talent for high tech, the Japanese are taking health care technology to the next level. Examples include practical devices such as Sanyo's human washing machines or robots designed for human companionship and basic communications, such as Mitsubishi's Wakamaru.

Wakamaru Robots


Toyota has been endeavouring to promote the widespread use of robots in everyday life, showing off its variety of robots, including a violin playing model described by David Silverberg.

Toyota's Violin Playing Robot


Another sophisticated robot in the news, written about by momentsintime was Kansei, created at Meiji University's School of Science and Technology, which can react with realistic facial expressions when an impressive self-updating list of 500,000 possible keywords are mentioned.



Leah informed us that there is also a childlike model by the Japan Science and Technology Agency, known as CB2, with a biometric silicone body, designed to imitate the body language of a toddler.



Let us not forget the robot muscle suit that DJ's own robot museinspiredart wrote about, having a look at a website describing Dr. Keijirou Yamamoto's Wearable Power Assist Suit, it's not quite a proper mecha (a la Anime) yet, but the possibilities ten years into the future are beginning to look incredible.



In the Workplace

Robot equipment is already used in manufacturing, but we may not be expecting to see them inside an office environment, until you find out that a company called People Staff, a major temporary staffing agency from Japan has hired 10 Wakamara robots. Yes you heard me right, pinktentacle.com reported that the human resources agency has them at their disposal for use as dispatch workers. They can be hired out for about $1000 per day and are capable of recognizing faces, having simple conversations with their 10,000 word vocabulary and performing simple manual tasks.

Honda's ASIMO robots, which look like little spacemen are highly advanced with technology that allows them to act autonomously. They move with grace, are able to step out of the way of oncoming human traffic and can perform useful tasks, such as carrying a tray or pushing a cart. They even know when to charge themselves up when their battery is getting low. Robot enthusiasts must check out the ASIMO website that Honda has devoted to their creation, as they continue to develop new features and take them on a world promotional tour. All kinds of cool videos and pictures of the ASIMO robots in action can be found there.

Two ASIMO robots serving refreshments in coordination


Robots you can buy

Even though these robots and gear already mentioned sound great, they are quite expensive today. Wakamaru costs $14,260, plus monthly maintenance. Sanyo's human washing machines cost $50,000, but in Japan this is approximately equal to the annual wages of two Filipino nurses. With the Japanese government's push for home care for the elderly, these kinds of expenses are considered to be absorbed and are more than a hint of the direction that the country is taking. Twendy-One is expected to cost $200,000 and won't be available until 2015, but by that time, we can only imagine the competition from other manufacturers getting into the game.

Fortunately for normal people seeking robots, productdose.com put together a list of top ten robots that you can buy. Many of the items are toys of course, kids have most of the fun, but then there is the Roomba robot vacuum, that keeps your house clean. Unfortunately it doesn't do stairs, but how cool is that anyways?

Roomba


Then there is ZMP Nuvo, a 15" tall robot companion that responds to 50 spoken commands, such as telling you the time, when you ask, or coming when you call. It also has a digital camera in its head and a wireless LAN transmitter that can send images to your cell phone.

ZMP Nuvo


White Box Robotics 914 PC-Bot is a good example of an R2D2 type bot, capable of moving around, but also a fully functional computer. It's pricier than most laptops, but hey at least you can teach it to navigate its way around your house. It seems to have been designed with geeks in mind, who can develop the software using the application development platform. There are also loads of add on parts that can be purchased for it.



For the robotics enthusiast, the Balbot Advanced development kit is even cheaper than the PC-Bot and is a self balancing robot, ready for the ingenuity of its owner to turn it into a fully functional creation.



Robots in Space

One cannot really talk about robots in completion without mentioning the complex creations that we send into space. From the Robot Arm of the Space Shuttle to the Mars Rovers, to space probes sent to the outer reaches of our solar system, billions of dollars go into research and development of our mechanical extensions of the senses.

For 25 years, since the second shuttle mission, the Canadaarm Robot Arm has been providing the 'brawn' to lift heavy equipment and the 'delicate touch' to perform precision tasks.

The arm has six joints – two in the shoulder, one at the elbow and three in the wrist. It’s hollow – on Earth it wouldn’t be able to support even its own weight. But in space it can lift more than 586,000 pounds. Thanks to some upgrades, the 50-foot-long arm is accurate enough to put a peg in a hole given 60/1000 of an inch in clearance.


In the cold vacuum of space, manipulation robots are very important and the Canadaarm will be remembered as one of the pioneers.

Canadarm Robotic Arm


The twin Mars Rovers Spirit and Opportunity have been acting as our robotic geologists, a sensory extension of ourselves, searching for answers about the history of water on the red planet. Spirit landed on Mars on January 3rd PST and Opportunity landed on January 24 PST, 2004 Earth time. They recently celebrated a fourth anniversary of tirelessly searching for and characterizing the rocks and soil of the Mars surface.

Mars Rover


The Dark Side

The future of robots among us does not always fill us with inspiration, unless perhaps you are the winner of a lucrative defense contract, paid to design robots that can kill. While the Japanese are busy developing care for their elderly, the U.S. Pentagon is spending billions on replacing human soldiers with machines.

Using robotics in war is nothing new, the Goliath tracked mines were remote control devices, used by the Germans in World War II to perform tasks such as destroying tanks, demolishing buildings and of course infantry.

British Soldiers with captured Goliath Tracked Mines


The Dutch developed the Goalkeeper CIWS (Close In Weapon System) for use on ships or airfields in 1979, which uses radar to track the trajectory of incoming missiles or ballistic shells and then attempts to destroy them with its auto cannon.

Goalkeeper CIWS


In the modern age of technology the robots that are being used in the battlefield today and designed for the future offer possibilities that are approaching the realm of science fiction.

The robots being built by the U.S. Future Combat Systems program range from those that are designed to assist soldiers in dangerous situations, to reconnaissance, to those that can be used to kill a human.

iRobot, the same manufacturer of the Roomba vacuum makes Small Unmanned Ground Vehicles. The SUGV is a tactical reconnaissance robot designed to assist soldiers by accessing dangerous or otherwise inaccessible locations. In recent news, the testing of 25 SUGV robots has been accelerated in order to make them available to soldiers in the field as early as possible.

The SUGV


The BEAR robot by Vecna Technologies, with its teddy bear shaped head, powerful upper body and tracked legs would be a welcome sight to wounded soldiers, as it is designed to carry them from the battlefield.

BEAR Robot


Not everything being developed is intended to save lives, although the replacement of human soldiers in the battlefield is undoubtedly the persuasive argument that will be used to justify spending billions more on weapons that can wield war without tears.

Since 1995, the U.S. Air Force has been using the MQ-1 Predator system, which consists of four remote controlled aircraft with sensors, a ground station, satellite communication link and 55 ground crew. They have been used in combat over Afghanistan, Bosnia, Serbia, Iraq, and Yemen.

An Armed MQ-1 Predator


Foster-Miller has developed the popular TALON bots capable of both reconnaissance and combat, deployed since 2000 in Bosnia and was even used for search and recovery at Ground Zero after the September 11th tragedy. They have been used since the beginning of the war in Iraq, saving lives with their bomb diffusal capabilities.

There is also a HAZMAT TALON that will be available soon, which comes equipped with chemical, gas, temperature and radiation sensors that can be displayed in real time to a hand-held display.

A SWORD is a weaponized version of the TALON, three of which have recently been deployed in Iraq, armed with M249 machine guns.

TALON robot in 'robo-soldier' mode with gun mounted.


Available for half the price of a TALON, the Robotex AH is a lethal little remote control robot with a gun turret, pictured here in a video by ex-Disney imagineer Terry Izumi made for Fortune magazine. According to an article by Susan Duclos, it was built by self-taught engineer Adam Gettings, with assistance from shotgun maker Jerry Baber and Terry Izumi. The group plan to show off the armoury, which includes both the AH model and a smaller MH, relying on the public outcry to help sell the devices to the U.S. Government.

"If moms and dads around the country find out this system is available while their sons are off sopping up bullets in Iraq, they're going to tear the White House down," he said in the Fortune article.

Adam Gettings with an MH Robotex - photo by Chris Mueller


The German military has been using unmanned aircraft drones for some 30 years, but they have also begun to develop robots for ground missions such as the ASENDRO, which is capable of reconnaissance and EOD (Explosive Ordinance Disposal) with its manipulator arm and gripper that can be controlled in sync with the operator's hand movement.

ASENDRO Modular Robot


The list of robotic military devices is growing, and it's evident in armed forces around the world. South Korea plans to use robot sentries on the heavily guarded border with North Korea.

Today none of these robotic military machines are autonomous, they must be controlled by humans, so the idea that wars waged completely by robots is still a potential prospect for the future. However, Joe Dyer, iRobot’s president of Government & Industrial Robots Division said that the robot warrior SWORDs are being tested for the ability to 'think' for themselves. This “disruptive technology,” Dyer said, is “going to change the way we fight, the way we live—it’s going to change our entire lives.”

Until that time all that training that kids have had with computer war games may eventually pay off with gigs in the military controlling these kinds of deadly toys, hopefully keeping the friendly fire casualties to a minimum.

Artificial Intelligence

Though it has been dreamed about since ancient times Artificial Intelligence is still a long way away from developing a sentient computer like Hal 9000, from 2001: A Space Odyssey.



However, since the age of digital computers began researchers have had access to tools that can actually help humankind achieve those dreams, by giving sentience to robots. Deductive reasoning and problem solving algorithms can require heavy processing resources, but since the 80's and 90's successful methods for dealing with uncertain or incomplete information have been devised.

Ontological engineering is the science of representing the knowledge of everything that is known to exist. However even though a computer's 'head' can be filled with factual information, commonsense concepts must be taught with tedious care. Working assumptions are common in human thought and many things are not simply true or false, but more abstract. Humans also have an inner intuitive sense that helps us articulate things that are not necessarily represented with facts.

Planning is another major ingredient of intelligence, with which an intelligent agent has the ability to see the possibilities of the future and take action to achieve goals.

Learning is already being developed to some degree, with self updating programs, and recognition software but key challenges that must be met are the ability to adapt to new things based on experience, and differentiate between right and wrong.

Communication is an important trait that even the current breed of robots must exhibit if they are to be perceived as anything like a human. The prospect of a machine having the ability to interpret different languages, parse phrases and make sense of the myriad of variations in dialect and syntax habits, makes the capabilities of C3P0 quite unbelievable.



For robots, perception comes in the form of sensors, which are already widely used in everything from motion sensor lighting for your side door to delicate instruments on space probes.

In order to be useful in any way, robots need to be able to move and manipulate physical objects. Robotics is already quite advanced in terms of the ability to plan and learn a path based on sensory information and past experience.

Artificial Intelligence researchers deem that in order to be 'AI-complete', all of the most difficult kinds of problems must be solved to have an agent that is 'strong AI', which is to say that it can match or exceed human capabilities.

Future Possibilities

As humankind continues its quest to create beings in our own image, one may wonder, what about the morals in all of this? If we give robots sentience and expect them to work as slaves to do our bidding, is this correct? Perhaps it is better to leave them as semi-autonomous machines, if we want them to perform the tasks that no human being should have to do, such as clean the sludge from an oil tanker or disarm a bomb.

Science fiction is full of examples of robots taking over the world, revolting against humanity or helping us attain higher levels of understanding as we explore the universe. It's undeniable that we will be continuing to rely on machines in ways that were presented to us as visions by science fiction, but with the escalation of modern technology are becoming a distinct reality.

Our technology is evolving at a rate that our own human awareness is struggling to keep up with. As Ray Bradbury once said;

"Anything you dream is fiction, and anything you accomplish is science, the whole history of mankind is nothing but science fiction"


When it comes to the evolution of robots, by the time we get to the point where a robot is told to do something and the robot replies 'No', what then? Hopefully it's not too late to change the program.
article:249157:20::0
4 subscribers
Subscribe To This Thread[?] :
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Chris V. (cgull)
    #1
    Great post Ring, beautiful and detailed compilation. This is what the future will look like. It is amazing how many different thing robots does. You should also add Mars Rovers to this extensive list. Well done again
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Helena Handbasket
    #2
    What cgull said ......... 8 )
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Ringwraith
    #3
    Thanks, it was a pleasure to write. The deeper I got into it, the more I found there was to write about! You're absolutely right cgull, I'm working on an update for space robots as we speak!
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #4
    Really detailed article, Ringwraith...great job!

    Yep...the future is coming at us full-out...it's hard to keep up with all the advances sometimes!
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Ringwraith
    #5
    Thanks Sky! I added a space section, as per cgull's suggestion. There are just so many possibilities.
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Bob Ewing
    #6
    Excellent piece, i am more with Will Smith in I Robot when it comes to robots.
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  David Silverberg
    #7
    I've always been fascinated with the idea of robots being create to help humans, rather than hinder them. Unmanned military vehicles is one example, as are bomb-sniffing robots. Thing is, if left unchecked, robot creation could spiral out of control in a way that is more dystopic or Orwellian. Is that the kind of future we want?
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Ringwraith
    #8
    Thing is, if left unchecked, robot creation could spiral out of control in a way that is more dystopic or Orwellian. Is that the kind of future we want?


    It's an important question, when you consider the growing intelligence and role of robots in our society. The replacement of the manufacturing worker with a machine is almost cliche, but it's very real and still going on. Those Wakamaru robots acting as receptionists are cute and novel right now, but their heavy industry counterparts have been part of the workforce for years.
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Susan Duclos
    #9
    Excellent piece.
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Mr Garibaldi
    #10
    Fantastic article. Just don't mind those of us over here who are watching to make sure that they don't become self-aware...

    ;)
  • avatar Posted Jan 26, 2008 by  Ringwraith
    #11
    Thanks Susan, your report about the BEAR robot helped to pull together the section on the soldier saving possibilities of the military robots.

    Thanks Mike. It's hard to say, but we may actually live to see a time when we find them looking back at us.
  • avatar Posted Jan 27, 2008 by  Chris V. (cgull)
    #12
    They can compliment us well in some areas, but they shouldn't replace humans, otherwise too many will be out of work like the car manufacturing. I saw one video about the BMW plant in South Carolina, the whole thing is automated only at the end there are humans. I bookmarked it, if anybody wants to know about Robots, they can come here first. Well done Ring.
  • avatar Posted Jan 27, 2008 by  Ringwraith
    #13
    I agree, it's tempting to want them to do all of the dirty work for us, but nobody wants to hear 'You've been replaced by a machine' If that's what the BMW plant in S. Carolina is like, I can only imagine what the Japanese car factories are like, many of these friendlier robots are being produced by them.

    BTW, speaking of Japanese car manufacturers, I just had to add a blurb about Honda's ASIMO robots in the article. It's scary how advanced they are.
  • avatar Posted Jan 27, 2008 by  Helena Handbasket
    #14
    Thing is, if left unchecked, robot creation could spiral out of control in a way that is more dystopic or Orwellian. Is that the kind of future we want?


    I don't. I don't want that future for anyone. But who will stop the spiralling?

    Just don't mind those of us over here who are watching to make sure that they don't become self-aware...
  • avatar Posted Jan 27, 2008 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #15
    Nor do I want that kind of future either.
  • avatar Posted Jan 27, 2008 by  Ringwraith
    #16
    Not many people want the kind of future described in '1984' 'The Matrix' or 'Terminator'

    Robots are already part of our reality. They don't have any kind of real sentience yet, so we're at a stage that we can actually think about controls for the software.

    Isaac Asimov wrote the three laws of robotics in his 1942 book 'Runaround' They featured in the recent iRobot film.

    1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.

    2. A robot must obey orders given to it by human beings, except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.

    3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.


    Flawed? Maybe, as shown in the movie, where the robot weighs the decision to save the kid from drowning, hence sewing the protagonist's distrust of them.
  • avatar Posted Jan 30, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #17
    Well done. Robots are good to have.

    I have already used up my second Roomba.
  • avatar Posted Jan 30, 2008 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #18
    @ Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    Well done. Robots are good to have.

    I have already used up my second Roomba.


    Do they really work that well, Bart?
  • avatar Posted Jan 30, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #19
    @ Debra Myers (skyangel)
    Do they really work that well, Bart?
    They do, Debra. However, you do have to take into account that they are robotic vacuum cleaners, not a second coming of Albert Einstein.

    For example, a classical vacuum cleaner will try to suck up cables, laces, cords... so will Roomba. That means that you need to prepare a room before Roomba can safely clean it.

    Roomba is not an industrial strenghth vacuum cleaner. It is great at keeping rooms reasonably clean, it is not great at turning pigpens in shiny showrooms.

    Also, it seems to last a lot less long than claimed. It seems to last a year before it starts to act funny. That makes it seem expensive. However, since Roomba does free me from vacuuming myself, I consider it money well spent.
  • avatar Posted Jan 30, 2008 by  Ringwraith
    #20
    Thanks Bart. Those are good points you make about the Roomba vacuum. The one person I know that has one just uses it on carpet and hardwood floors. She has a cat and says that it picks up the hair pretty good. She wishes it could do stairs though!

    It makes sense that you would have to have a certain level of clear floors for it to get the job done without interference. I wonder if you had a pair of pants or something on the floor for a long time if it would learn to go around that area and avoid it for good. lol
  • avatar Posted Jan 31, 2008 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #21
    I don't know anyone that has a Roomba so I was just curious. My thoughts were that they probably didn't get the floor as clean as manually doing them yourself. I'll save my money and just do it myself! LOL!
  • avatar Posted Feb 2, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #22
    @ RingwraithThanks Bart. Those are good points you make about the Roomba vacuum. The one person I know that has one just uses it on carpet and hardwood floors. She has a cat and says that it picks up the hair pretty good. She wishes it could do stairs though!

    It makes sense that you would have to have a certain level of clear floors for it to get the job done without interference. I wonder if you had a pair of pants or something on the floor for a long time if it would learn to go around that area and avoid it for good. lol
    That would be a fun thought. Unfortunately, Roomba doesn't work that way. It does not create an internal memory of the layout of a room. It works more like a billiard ball. All its software is intended to do is to avoid that it gets physically stuck somewhere, and that it does not get stuck in an endless loop.
  • avatar Posted Feb 2, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #23
    @ Debra Myers (skyangel)
    I don't know anyone that has a Roomba so I was just curious. My thoughts were that they probably didn't get the floor as clean as manually doing them yourself. I'll save my money and just do it myself! LOL!
    I think I have given the wrong impression, Debra. Roomba is probably better than a human at keeping a room clean, but it does have some limitations. It will get stuck on threads, power cables and the like (as would any other vacuum without the brain power of its owner). It will not clean corners. It is round, so it cannot get there. However, it will often be able to clean under beds, furniture... where humans cannot go (depending on the clearance).

    In my opinion, Roomba leaves your room cleaner than a human, at the condition that you use it often. The spots it'll have missed on day one, it will most likely not miss on day two, etc.

    Roomba does take its time, i.e. it is slow. However, who cares? We don't have to watch it and follow it (except the first times, because it so much fun to watch!).
  • avatar Posted Feb 2, 2008 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #24
    @ Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    I think I have given the wrong impression, Debra. Roomba is probably better than a human at keeping a room clean, but it does have some limitations. It will get stuck on threads, power cables and the like (as would any other vacuum without the brain power of its owner). It will not clean corners. It is round, so it cannot get there. However, it will often be able to clean under beds, furniture... where humans cannot go (depending on the clearance).

    In my opinion, Roomba leaves your room cleaner than a human, at the condition that you use it often. The spots it'll have missed on day one, it will most likely not miss on day two, etc.

    Roomba does take its time, i.e. it is slow. However, who cares? We don't have to watch it and follow it (except the first times, because it so much fun to watch!).


    Thanks, Bart for the clarification! I bet it would be fun to watch! I know having something like that with the grand kids around...they'd be wanting to chase it around, step on it or something "childish"! LOLOL!
  • avatar Posted Feb 2, 2008 by  Ringwraith
    #25
    @ Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    That would be a fun thought. Unfortunately, Roomba doesn't work that way. It does not create an internal memory of the layout of a room. It works more like a billiard ball. All its software is intended to do is to avoid that it gets physically stuck somewhere, and that it does not get stuck in an endless loop.


    Thanks for the clarification. I thought they had some capacity to learn the area. Maybe some future generation of them will. The fact that it can't really get into the corners is a pretty big limitation too. I guess it does the main work for you, leaving it up to the humans to take care of the detail work.
  • avatar Posted Feb 3, 2008 by  Bart B. Van Bockstaele
    #26
    @ Ringwraith
    Thanks for the clarification. I thought they had some capacity to learn the area. Maybe some future generation of them will. The fact that it can't really get into the corners is a pretty big limitation too. I guess it does the main work for you, leaving it up to the humans to take care of the detail work.
    There are other robotic vacuum cleaners that do make a map of the room. The Electrolux comes to mind. However, that one costs about 10 times as much, and it is twice as high, meaning it does not nearly clean as much as the Roomba.

    The fact that Roomba does not do corners is indeed annoying, but essentially unavoidable in this stage, I think. It must be said that it does use a small flexible brush to put dirt in its pathway, and that this make up in a large part for its inability to do corners. The part it cannot get to, is very small indeed.

Add a Comment

You have to Login or Register to comment


Email:
Password:
Remember meForgot password?