The Power of Citizen Journalism
Post News ($)»     Post Blog»     Upload Image»     Groups»     Events»     Alerts»     How do I ...»
Email Print Share

Email this article

Recipient email:
Your email:
optional
Message:
optional

article imageJapan's Internet access speed 30 times faster than connections in U.S.

Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  Chris V. (cgull) in Technology | 14 comments | 1928 views
Next in Technology
Related News
Advertising
The internet speed inJapan is 61 megabits per second, or nearly 30 times faster than the U.S.’ broadband speed of 1.97 megabits per second. Communication Workers of America are now warning the U.S. to improve speed or lose big in the global economy.
The USA trails other industrialized nations in high-speed Internet access and may never catch up unless quick action is taken by public-policymakers, a report commissioned by the Communications Workers of America warns.
The median U.S. internet speed connection is 1.97 megabits per second compared to Japan’s 61 megabits per second. Other countries that have a higher speed than US are South Korea (45 megabits), France (17 megabits) and Canada (7 megabits).

Communication Workers of America president, Larry Cohen, said:
We have pathetic speeds compared to the rest of the world. People don't pay attention to the fact that the country that started the commercial Internet is falling woefully behind.
I believe it's woeful to have such low speeds in the U.S. While speed may not be a big issue now, the near future will demand it, with such things as research and entertainment industries requiring a speedy connection.

A 10-megabyte file takes about 15 seconds to download with a 5-megabit connection. Download time with a 545-kilobit connection, about the entry-level speed in many areas: almost 2.5 minutes. With 60 megabits, it takes about 0.16 seconds. With large movie files downloading this becomes especially painful, as downloading a 4.5 GB file at 5 megabit connection (the U.S. "high speed" connection), it takes 15 minutes, where as the high-speed 60 megabit connection in Japan can download the file in a mere 1.25 seconds.
Broadband speed is a function of network capacity: The more capacity you have, the more speed you can deliver. Speed, in turn, allows more and better Internet applications, such as photo sharing and video streaming. Superfast speeds are imperative for critical applications such as telemedicine.
Speed is also important for communities and districts who want to draw businesses to the area.

Cohen says it is extremely important for the policy makers to act fast to maintain the U.S.’s position in global economy, and to create more jobs.
The CWA report is based on input from 80,000 broadband users (less than 5% of respondents used dial-up). In addition to drawing comparisons with other countries, the report ranks U.S. states on median download speeds. (Upload speeds are also rated.)
The Federal Communications Commission, which oversees all broadband market considers “200 kilobits per second” as the bench mark for broadband speed. This was set 12 years ago. Today, this speed is not even recognized as broadband speed in many countries. The FCC says it is now thinking about updating its definition.

Among the states, Rhode Island has the highest speed connection which tops at 5 megabits, while the slowest is in South Dakota less than 1 megabit speed.

I hope they increase the speed of broadband; the current speed has been there for a long time. I read in a previous article that cable providers are resistant to change and content with profits generated, unless others force the issue they or the politicians won’t change the status quo.
Source: usatoday.com external
article:200308:11::0
6 subscribers
Subscribe To This Thread[?] :
  • avatar Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  MDee
    #1
    I guess Japan is ahead of us in many ways more than we thought.
    Good post.
    MDee
  • avatar Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  Chris Hogg
    #2
    This is amazing, while truly sad at the same time. From what I know, both the U.S. and Canada would fit in this comparison to Japan and I really hope there is one company out there that understands the value of speed and how it can increase its business.

    Canada is especially backward, with our Internet cable companies charging a fortune for high-speed in comparison to other countries. Internet and cellphones are always a touchy subjects in Canada because the government regulates them into oblivion, making them bloated, inefficient and expensive.

    I can't even imagine what it would be like to download a 4 GB file in less than two seconds. The laptops and PCs in Japan must be equipped with massive hard drive space to maintain this.
  • avatar Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  Bob Ewing
    #3
    faster please.
  • avatar Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  Chris V. (cgull)
    #4
    @ MDee:
    I guess Japan is ahead of us in many ways more than we thought.
    Good post.
    MDee
    Most of the time they use US Patents and ideas and modify it. The reason they allocate more resources compared to US, that is the problem we have. The Congress is not initiating, the cable carriers are content with what is now, so the speeds are lagging here.

    @ Chris Hogg:
    This is amazing, while truly sad at the same time. From what I know, both the U.S. and Canada would fit in this comparison to Japan and I really hope there is one company out there that understands the value of speed and how it can increase its business.

    Canada is especially backward, with our Internet cable companies charging a fortune for high-speed in comparison to other countries. Internet and cellphones are always a touchy subjects in Canada because the government regulates them into oblivion, making them bloated, inefficient and expensive.

    I can't even imagine what it would be like to download a 4 GB file in less than two seconds. The laptops and PCs in Japan must be equipped with massive hard drive space to maintain this.
    Chris, the hard drives are getting cheaper and cheaper, so it shouldn't be a problem. I saw 500GB portable for $100. Or if you have online storage at Mozy.com it is only $4.99 unlimited storage so you can transfer it there.
  • avatar Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #5
    Good post, cgull.

    I received an email the other day about this very thing! There was a link that you could go to to check your own speed...here it is.
  • avatar Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  Chris V. (cgull)
    #6
    @ Debra Myers (skyangel):
    Good post, cgull.

    I received an email the other day about this very thing! There was a link that you could go to to check your own speed...here it is.
    Thanks skyangel, I am embarrassed to test the speed, it should be about 1.5 megabits I think. Hope they improve the speeds soon.
  • avatar Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #7
    I tested mine...here are my own results:



  • avatar Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  Chris Hogg
    #8
    Very interesting website. It's amazing to see how much faster my connection in Canada is compared to you Sky. I'm also on a wireless connection right now which can be slower.

    These are my results:


  • avatar Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  Chris V. (cgull)
    #9
    Good to see these graphs Skyangel.

    Chris, Canada has a faster service than US, is your government taking any steps to increase the speeds? Here we are just waiting.

    I sent the letter to the Congressman via that link, hope they will listen.
  • avatar Posted Jun 27, 2007 by  Debra Myers (skyangel)
    #10
    I also sent a letter to my Congressman, and forwarded the email to everyone that I know! The funny thing is that I thought that I was doing good having DSL...not! And this proves that.

    Chris...all of you that live in Canada are pretty lucky compared to us here in the US. Maybe some day we'll catch up! LOL!

    cgull...you are welcome for the graphs...I thought that maybe once people saw what my upload/download times were, they'd check their own out.
  • avatar Posted Jun 28, 2007 by  barryb
    #11
    Originally I was thinking Japan had the edge because it is so small geographically but since Canada is faster than the US that theory falls apart.

    I know that Japan is way ahead of us in cell phone technology too. I guess it's all a matter of what the local government sees as a priority what it doesn't.
  • avatar Posted Jun 28, 2007 by  Alex Chumak
    #12
    @ Chris Hogg:
    I can't even imagine what it would be like to download a 4 GB file in less than two seconds. The laptops and PCs in Japan must be equipped with massive hard drive space to maintain this.


    Sounds amazing, but you are still bottlenecked by other constraints. Main one, hard drive. It will only be able to write few megabytes per second, so even though you can have data come in very fast it will take much longer to save it to the hard drive, which effectively caps your speed.
  • avatar Posted Jun 28, 2007 by  Chris V. (cgull)
    #13
    @ Alex Chumak:
    Sounds amazing, but you are still bottlenecked by other constraints. Main one, hard drive. It will only be able to write few megabytes per second, so even though you can have data come in very fast it will take much longer to save it to the hard drive, which effectively caps your speed.
    Great point, I found this Hard drive with a
    Data Transfer Rate: 480Mbps External Maximum USB 2.0,
    Up to 46MBps Sustained
    , with a lower value, we can still expect a faster download. So hopefully with higher speed hard drives, we will be able to download at a faster rate. I think the whole industry should be in sync, hope they get their acts together and give us a better broadband experience than what is now. If not they should let Google and others to do it, I am sure they will do it if given permission.
  • avatar Posted Jun 30, 2007 by  barryb
    #14
    The hard drive theory also fails to take into account the fact that computers in Japan have the same hard drives as computers in North America. And SATA drives are generally much faster than the older IDE drives.

    There are other countries that are ulra-wired too. Different countries, different priorities.

Add a Comment

You have to Login or Register to comment


Email:
Password:
Remember meForgot password?